• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Diamond Jim's Steakhouse – Premier Prime Rib & Classic Supper Club Dining in Hales Corners, WI

Diamond Jim's Steakhouse in Hales Corners, WI, is a classic supper club known for its exceptional prime rib and perfectly cooked steaks like filet mignon and bone-in ribeye. The cozy, old-school atmosphere pairs wonderfully with attentive, friendly service, enhancing the dining experience. Signature dishes such as twice-baked potatoes, fried eggplant appetizer, and hard-to-find desserts like schaum torte and banana cream pie add unique charm. Guests rave about flavorful seafood options, hearty entrees, and rich, satisfying sides. Though slightly pricey, Diamond Jim’s offers a memorable, indulgent meal that makes every visit feel special and truly worth it.

Diamond Jim's Steakhouse at a glance

  • Address 11811 Janesville Rd, Hales Corners, WI 53130, United States
  • Phone +1 414-425-7777
  • Restaurant type Steak house , Banquet hall , Bar , Deli , Fine dining restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Diamond Jim's Steakhouse: Reviews & Ratings

Jody Merenick
5

Prime Rib was excellent and melted in your mouth. Enjoyed the French onion soup and the pomegranate martini and my husband's black Manhattan were delicious. We were visiting for the night and went to China Lights and our dining experience made our night perfect. Great service and food. I really wanted prime rib and this did not disappoint.

Rebecca Larson
5

The food is so delicious! I recommend the filet mignon! They have desserts that are hard to find elsewhere: schaum torte and banana cream pie- yum! It's not a big supper club so make a reservation! You won't regret it!

Tuan Bui
5

The prime rib was made by God. The service was excellent and the atmosphere was cozy. But yeah, the PRIME RIB.

Sandi Landowski
5

I very much enjoy the supper club atmosphere. Wait staff are very friendly. We started with the fried eggplant appetizer, which were very large cuts dipped in a light and crispy batter and served with lemon wedges, parm cheese, and marinara sauce. ($12). Soup or salad comes with an entrée along with a small bread basket and relish tray. The four piece fried chicken was wonderful and priced at $25. I had the half rack of ribs for $22 and paid a small upcharge for the twice baked potato. I had a lot left over. The husband ordered the bone in ribeye, which he said was cooked to perfection. The daughter also ordered a piece of banana cream pie to go. Everything was absolutely delicious.

Diane Bloor
5

Our party consisted of 5 adults and 3 children celebrating Mother's Day on Saturday. Everybody thoroughly enjoyed their entree's. The steaks were cooked perfect, the twice baked potatoes were amazing, juicy tender lobster and scallops, the prime was a true flavorful experience. We even ordered after dinner ice cream drinks, turtle cheese cake, apple pie served with cinnamon ice cream and the kids had vanilla ice cream. The only negative was the the tables were too close together and people had a hard time walking through without bumping your chair. We loved the old school steak house feel and decor. It was a bit on the pricey side. The prices certainly went up considerably from the menus posted on Facebook. We don't mind paying money for great food so Diamond Jim's is now on the top of my list for fine, delicious food!!!

Jill Haushalter
5

We were looking for a late dinner due to working late on a Tuesday night and to our surprise, Diamond Jims was open and still serving food. If that wasnt enough they have prime rib and fish fries every night of the week! We were in heaven. Kelly was the most kind and attentive bartender and she served our meals to us at the bar. I had the broiled fish and it was good. My husband got the fried chicken and ate every last bite. This place has been around forever, now I know why!

Mike R
5

How anybody can give this restaurant anything less than a 5 star rating is a mystery. I was presented with one of the leanest prime ribs in my lift and cooked perfectly to order! Their Banana Cream Pie should be their only dessert on the menu it is that good. The restaurant is a throw back to the golden era and the service is exceptional.

Location

  • Diamond Jim's Steakhouse
    Diamond Jim's Steakhouse
    11811 Janesville Rd, Hales Corners, WI 53130, United States Hotline: +1 414-425-7777

Diamond Jim's Steakhouse in Hales Corners, Wisconsin, is a true gem for steak lovers and supper club enthusiasts alike. This classic steakhouse combines an old-school atmosphere with an impressive menu that shines with both traditional and creative dishes. From the moment you step inside, you feel the warmth of a cozy, inviting environment paired with attentive, friendly service that makes every visit special.

The highlight here undeniably revolves around their expertly prepared steaks. The prime rib, celebrated by many patrons, is tender and flavorful, melting effortlessly in your mouth. The bone-in ribeye and New York strip stand out for their perfect sear and juicy texture, satisfying even the most discerning steak aficionados. For those seeking variety, the filet mignon carries a rich, buttery finish that melts with every bite.

Beyond beef, Diamond Jim’s offers a rich surf and turf collection. The cold water lobster tail, jumbo fried scallops, and bacon-wrapped scallops with garlic sauce deliver a refined coastal touch that balances the hearty meat dishes. The colossal fried mushrooms and colossally fried scallops add a tasty crunch, showcasing their mastery of deep-fried delicacies that never feel greasy or heavy.

The appetizers and starters create a delightful prelude to dinner. The relish tray, a staple supper club feature, along with their baked French onion soup, is deeply satisfying and thoughtfully prepared. The fried eggplant appetizer, dipped in light, crispy batter and served with lemon wedges and marinara sauce, is a standout, offering a fresh and crispy contrast.

Not-to-be-missed choices include the classic fish fry and French dip, each embodying tradition with a unique Diamond Jim's twist. Their soup and salad accompaniments, coupled with a small bread basket, complete a dining experience that is both comforting and elevated.

Equally impressive is the cocktail menu, featuring old-fashioned classics and inventive creations like the pomegranate martini and the black Manhattan. These cocktails complement the meal perfectly, adding to the charm and sophistication.

The dessert selection rounds out the experience beautifully. Rare finds like schaum torte and banana cream pie delight the palate and evoke nostalgia, making for a sweet ending to a memorable dinner.

In essence, Diamond Jim's Steakhouse offers more than just a meal; it delivers an experience steeped in tradition and quality. While it leans toward the pricier side, the consistency of well-executed dishes and warm hospitality makes every dollar worth it. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving expertly grilled steak and classic supper club fare, Diamond Jim’s stands out as a premier destination poised to satisfy and impress.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards